ESC2012 – Semi Final One – Live Notes
Hello lovely readers! I may not have been able to do my usual round of pre-Contests posts as thoroughly or as often as I would have liked, but I am here now for the live notes – which are really the best part of the blog, in my opinion. Per usual, I am writing these notes live as I am watching the Contest. A few things to note, I have the lyrics for each song pulled up, because, how can you judge a song contest without knowing the lyrics. Secondly, I know that, traditionally, I do not listen to the songs before they premiere live at the Contest, but this year, due to the extreme tightness of my schedule, I had to in order to get my prediction pieces done. So, I am actually quite familiar with the songs which is a major shift from how I normally write these live notes. Additionally, unlike previous years, I have not read about the stagings of the songs. Normally, I don’t listen to the entries and read about the rehearsals, this year, I am doing the reverse. Also, look for my tweets – #eurovisionobsession.
With that said, here are my pre-Contest predictions for who will qualify:
Since these have not changed since my previous post, I will not go into detail as to why I chose each of these songs.
So, let’s begin!
What an interesting arena! So many diamonds; definitely the most unique arena I’ve seen thus far for a Contest. The stage is rather nice, though! Looks like there’s not going to be an opening act for the semi-finals this year again. Did that third host say that she’s a lawyer? Why is a lawyer hosting? Did she remember to say Spain in the Big Five? (“France, Germany, Italy, United Kingdom” I don’t think she did).
No, El, Azerbaijan is not in Europe.
I see that Azerbaijan has returned to showing off the country for the post cards.
On to the entries:
Montenegro – Euro Neuro performed by Rambo Amadeus
Crna Gora has been saving up money for two years, and this is the best staging they could afford? I guess it works for the song. Speakin of which. It’s interesting, but I don’t quite think Europe will get it. Hopefully, Mr. Amadeus can avoid a null point.
Gereta’s voice is a little off. I think that she put down the violin, or least wait until the instrumental break. Not necessarily a winning performance, but I think good enough to get them through to the Final.
Greece – Aphrodisiac performed by Eleftheria Eleftheriou
Is the background singer so loud on purpose? This just feels so…cheap. This song had the potential for a really amazing performance, but instead, they settled for depending on a background singer to provide the majority of the vocal support, a scantily clad singer, and some weak dance moves. I know I said that this was My Number One rebirthed, but it’s not, it’s nowhere close. As much as I dislike My Number One, it won because it was fresh and well-performed. This was just stale.
Latvia – Beautiful Song performed by Anmary
She might have been born in 1980, but this entry and its staging is rather 1970. At least she and her backing singers are modestly clad. So, aside from the fact that this song is fairly forgettable, it’s rather presumptuous. I hate when entries declare themselves the winners and talk about all the fame that will result. But, I guess, what more could we expect from Latvia?
Albania – Suus performed by Rona Nishliu
I don’t know why the press give artists so much flack for performing in their own language, I rather prefer it. Excellent use of lights for the high notes! If only she remembered to hold the microphone up to her mouth the entire time. Did you hear that crowd reaction? They loved it! What a heart-wrenching performance – woohoo! This is one of my favorite entries – and this is why! Great job! She should move through, but she probably won’t, unfortunately.
Romania – Zaleilah performed by Mandinga
The moon walk would have been so much better if the mouthpiece of the bagpipe was actually in his mouth. Fire! Romania, right now, is the country to beat. I know that they can count on twelve points from Moldova and Spain, and probably several others.
Whoa, that was a cool camera effect – that long shot to close up to long, again at the start of the first chorus. I wonder why he isn’t using the catwalk – this seems like the perfect song for that – oh, there goes his brother, he took off down that thing! I wonder why they didn’t really show it. Fire! This is, what, the third or fourth pyrotechnics of the night? But, where is the wind machine? I do believe the Swiss are headed back to the Final.
I like these postcards – they’re doing a great job of showing off the country. I just thought of something, are those little diamonds in the audience this year’s green room? That would be rather interesting and I imagine rather frustrating for the artists who want to relax and decompress after their performance.
Belgium – Would You? performed by Iris
This is a sweet song, but ultimately rather forgettable. But she’s giving her all. I love it when a competitor, who probably realizes that she’s outmatched, still gives her all. Way to go Belgium! There’s no reason for you to feel bad about the outcome, Iris, you did the best you could with a weak song. Hold your head up high!
Finland – När Jag Blundar performed by Pernilla
I love how they make the flags on the Crystal Hall’s exterior! This song has a sweet story. The singer’s brother wrote it in honor of their mother (who’s there in Baku with them). I assume that’s him on the cello. What a wonderful sight for their mother to behold. I hope all three of them cherish these three minutes, because I doubt they will happen again. Thank you Finland for singing in NOT English, even if it isn’t your official language. I find it funny that we have to go to Finland to get an entry in Swedish, the first time the language has been on the ESC stage since 1998. A pretty song, but will be forgotten, much like Belgium.
Israel – Time performed by Izabo
Anyone else find it interesting that they talk about Azerbaijan being a “holy land” right before Israel’s performance? I like the 70’s sound of this song; I could totally image roller skating to this song. Unfortunately, even though Europe is behind the times, it’s not so far back that it will appreciate this entry to the fullest. The guitarist has his own mic, why is he coming over to the lead singer’s? What an interesting use of the backing singers.
This postcard fits nicely, as Monetta is a jazz singer by profession. Her eyes are so big! And her voice is so small! I’m sorry, but this sounds like something adults make to entertain children (the lyrics referring to sex aside, of course). Why is there a pilot and a doctor? Sorry, San Marino, another year in the semi-finals for you – better luck next year! How much more fun would this performance be if they had actual Facebook pages and Tweets floating around behind them, of fans from the 42 participating countries?
Cyprus – La La Love performed by Ivi Adamou
This always reminded me of something that Rihanna could sing. And like the Bahamian singer, Ivi is stunningly beautiful and sings just flat throughout her song. Again, we have the issue of backing singers who are too loud. Is the dance routine so rigorous that we need to have all four ladies at full blast to help Ivi out? The dance break and the bridge had some amazing camera direction – good job whoever directed this performance. While I like this song, the overbearing backing singers gave it a bit of an amateurish sound. It was more like something you would expect at a local community musician expo, not a continent-wide song pop contest. Hopefully, it’s better on Saturday.
Denmark – Should’ve Known Better performed by Soluna Samay
I don’t understand the bassist’s outfit – it seems rather out of place. Aside from that, this is nearly identical to the MGP performances of this song. There’s something that can be said for consistency. Well, actually, her voice is a little less whiny this time around, which is a very good thing.
Russia – Party for Everyone performed by Buranovskiye Babushki
Didn’t we already see that Baku is a sunny city? That’s a giant oven they have on stage! Which I guess makes sense since the song is about a them preparing a party for their children and grandchildren. The audience seems to be getting really into it! I wonder if they have enough pastries for everybody? That little short one has some nice moves!
Are they allowed to use the term “Golden Girls”?
So, I was right about the green room being out in the arena. Wow! Valentina Monetta has a rather deep voice!
Hungary – Sound of Our Hearts performed by Compact Disco
I wonder, if for the Final, every postcard is just going to say “Azerbaijan: Land of Fire!” and show things burning throughout the country. This entry is so…smug. Like the singer is saying, “Look at me! I am singing about the human condition! Aren’t I so artsy! Be inspired by me!”
Austria – Woki Mit Deim Popo performed by Trackshittaz
Whew! They’re keeping this thing moving – it’s only been 70 minutes since they’ve started and we’re already just about done with the presentation of the entries. Uh oh, I think the timing was slightly off with lighting effects. I’m glad they went with pole dancers as opposed to just three girls who shake their butts while holding poles. I’m glad that they toned down the entry from the National Selection performance, but they may have went a little too far – it definitely lacked a lot of the electricity it had during when they won in Austria.
So, I’m a HUGE fan of the song he took to the Moldovan national selection last year, Dorule. This song cannot touch the awesomeness that is Dorule. Though, this is pleasant and has a decent shot of moving through to Saturday, I think. It would have been more effective if there was an actual trumpet on stage somewhere, either one of the backing dancers could hold it or just a giant trumpet on the LED screen, something! There’s one at the end, at least. The choreography was really great, though.
Ireland – Waterline performed by Jedward
Hey, their hair is even worse than it was last year! WHAT ARE THEY WEARING?!?! I think we have this year’s Barbara Dex award. Perhaps they were aiming to get the infamous title renamed for themselves. Why are they jumping around, this is not that kind of song. They’re singing is not awful, but this song is dated and forgettable. If they didn’t have the name recognition that they did, this song would be dead last tonight. With any luck, Albania did enough to displace them from the projected Top Ten.
My Ten Favorite from tonight:
My Predictions for who will qualify to the Final (in no particular order)
Romania (probably the strongest performance of the night, all things considered)
Denmark (mass appeal soft ballad that was well sung)
Iceland (it’s a contender for victory and was performed well-enough to make it through to Saturday)
Cyprus (not a strong performance, but benefits from the fact that more than half make it through)
Greece (it’s Greece)
Russia (this song is immensely popular and makes people smile)
Ireland (yuck! but Jedward is popular enough to move through)
Switzerland (they had a strong performance)
Hungary (good enough song to move through, despite the singer’s smugness)
Albania (I think she did enough to earn a spot and Moldova did not)
That’s amazing! I see why this guy was awarded the highest Azerbaijani honor for a musician. It’s amazing, though, how similar musical and dance traditions can be across regions. His drumming is not far off from what one would expect in an Afro-Cuban tradition. And the dancing is not dissimilar from Balkan and Middle Eastern dances (which makes sense given Azerbaijan’s location). It’s amazing how different we all are from one another, yet so like each other at the same time. I love it!
All six of the pre-qualified entries are amazing and have a legitimate shot of being Top Ten (with Spain, in my opinion, having the best chance of winning among them). This year has yielded many great entries; unlike last year where there were many entries that were all equally average, this year we have a lot of songs that are equally strong.
I see that Jon Ola Sand is still not yet comfortable speaking on camera.
The actual qualifiers:
A. Romania – I am 1 for 1 in predicting the finalists, thus far
B. Moldova – 1 for 2
C. Iceland – 2 for 3
D. Hungary – 3 for 4
E. Denmark – 4 for 5
F. Albania – 5 for 6 (ooh! I wonder whom else I got wrong in addition to Moldova, hopefully Ireland)
G. Cyprus – 6 for 7
H. Greece – 7 for 8
I. Russia – 8 for 9 (and the audience goes wild!)
Either Ireland or Switzerland will get left behind, I’m guessing it’s the latter of the two, unfortunately
J. Ireland – 9 for 10 (yuck!)
First, El talks like a Kindergarten teacher. I don’t know if it’s intentional or just his accent, but it’s a bit annoying.
Second, I was 9 for 10 with the pleasant surprise of Albania making it through to the Final and the unpleasant correct prediction of Ireland moving through. The song is weak, the performance is weak, and I hope it gets crushed on Saturday.
Other pleasant surprises: Belgium was surprising good. I was not expecting much from since the song was so lackluster, but Iris gave a great performance. She gets my award for best on the night! Also, three out of the five non-English entries (Romania, Russia, and Albania) made it through – good for them!
Drawing for starting positions for the Final
Romania – 14, so, we can expect at least a decent placing for them
Moldova – 26, lucky man, that will definitely give him a boost. Maybe even top 15.
Iceland – 7, <insert sad trombone sound here> that might just slay there chance of contending for victory, but it will open the door for Spain (and possibly even Italy)
Hungary – 2, looks like Hungary will be back in the bottom five with that spot
Denmark – 15, dare I say a Top Ten finish for Ms. Samay, depends on who’s around her, I think
Albania – 3, well, she did say she’s just happy to be there and have the chance to sing again
Cyprus – 8, she still has an outside chance of winning, but should still finish Top Ten
Greece – 16, Top Ten is assured for the Hellenic Republic
Russia – 6, they come right before Iceland, which might actually help Iceland’s chances
Ireland – 23, blah! now they will get a placing much higher than they deserve
What we know now:
1. United Kingdom